Number 25 birthday cookies

A giant homemade version in cake form, crafted by the queen of baking herself: Anna Olson.

The secret is good-quality ingredients and a little love, too. However, it is the caramel pastry cream that is really the icing on this cake pun intended! The plain base makes it the perfect canvas for colourful fondant or fresh flowers.

It's perfect for that special someone who eats peanut butter straight from the jar. This triple layered confection is not only tasty, its white buttercream frosting is the perfect canvas for multi-coloured candles. It's lightly spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg, and whipping heavy cream into your cream cheese makes an extra fluffy frosting. The creamy ricotta and mascarpone filling really complements the classic combination of chocolate and mint.

Birthday Cookies Deliver To Your Door with Free Shipping

Layer after layer of moist chocolate cake with rich chocolate icing. Plus, a hint of espresso helps bring out the deep chocolate flavour. Made with four chocolate cake layers filled with freshly sliced strawberries, whipped cream and chocolate hazelnut spread, you won't be able to resist a second piece. It's truly a chocolate lover's dream. The combination of cinnamon, nutmeg and fresh ginger make this cake irresistible.

Nav Social Menu

The finishing touch is chunks of peanut butter cups arranged on top and at the base of the cake. It's the perfect way to end an elegant birthday soiree.

Navigation menu

Start Over. Next Gallery. Family reunion. Just-divorced bash? Just because?

Birthday Cake Pudding Cookies

Our standout sweets, unexpected breakfast breads, and delish coffee-to-go are always the way to go. Milk Bar's take on the traditional bagel! Flavors rotate, so inquire when ordering. Yummy and fresh as-is You can never go wrong with a Milk Bar layer cake for a celebration big or small! Gorgeous as-is or personalize yours with a custom message.

Your cake can be pre-cut upon request; additional fee applies. Need something even more special?

30 Easy Birthday Cake Ideas That Are Just as Creative as They Are Pretty

Inquire about our tiered celebration and wedding cake options. With a toasted oat crust and a gooey butter filling, Milk Bar Pie is a fan favorite.

Number Cake - Alphabet Cake - How to Make Cream Tart

Make an eye-catching and playful addition to your dessert table — a foot-high tower of Milk Bar's iconic cake truffles!